EXC work mgf - I wholeheartedly heartfully approve. Most exc, and as nick said - his promo was obvious and exactly why they had to go
Excellent show, was great fun guessing! And I think JĂșlio provided the evidence that we were right to eliminate promos: He guessed mine because of it. Therefore: Excellent idea, excellent execution and a great decision to eliminate promos.
That was great fun! I think I guessed 6 or 7, and so many people guessed me for loads of songs. Superb idea! Top marks as ever, jw
This is a great idea imo and I don't know about anyone else but the songs seem much more memorable by having the 2nd recap played. Like I said in chat though, to make it more of a surprise I think if people are going to guess, they also need to deliberately wrongly guess their own song as it could become a bit obvious to some if someone goes silent when their entry is played.
I need to devise a method to keep count of my guesses, but it's fun nevertheless. The experiment was a success and it will probably be even more fun with a day of speculation, if the anonymous reveal is on Saturdays.